Sentencing and criminal history
The most recent (15 February 2018) Criminal Justice Statistics Quarterly bulletin (covering September 2016 – September 2017) confirms recent key trends — the lowest number of people since modern records began (1970) were dealt with by the courts, but the proportion of people imprisoned for indictable offences rose again and that average length of sentence increased too. Here are the main points as summarised by the bulletin:
Since the trend, and the underlying reasons for it, have remained the same for the last two or three years, I decided I would do something more interesting with this post than just give you chapter and verse on the headline developments in more detail.
Instead, I want to introduce you to a fabulous resource from the Ministry of Justice: their interactive Sankey diagram which lets you see how groups of people’s offending history is reflected in how the courts sentence them.
In case you don’t know (and I certainly didn’t) Sankey diagrams display flows and their quantities in proportion to one another. The width of the arrows or lines are used to show their magnitudes, so the bigger the arrow, the larger the quantity of flow. Flow arrows or lines can combine together or split through their paths on each stage of a process.
The MoJ Sankey diagram allows you to focus on a particular group of offenders by age or gender and/or a particular type of offence and lets you see instantly how the criminal justice system sentences them.
You can all see differences in sentencing on a yearly basis going back to 2007.
The diagram is delightfully intuitive and engaging and I spent a happy half hour trying out all the permutations.
It’s important to remember the limits of what the diagram can tell you. For instance a larger proportion of women than men receive a suspended sentence for sexual offences (while immediate custody rates are similar) and while a very small proportion of men are dealt with by an absolute discharge, no women receive this court disposal. However, the profile of sexual offending by men and women is different, so you are not necessarily comparing like with like.
Nevertheless, there’s much to be learned by this interactive approach and you can see why some say:
A Sankey diagram is worth a 100 pie charts.
I hope you find the examples I’ve chosen interesting and, more importantly, you will go and try out the resource yourself.
Adult men sentenced for sexual offences
Adult women sentenced for sexual offences
The next two slides show the difference in the overall sentencing patterns for juvenile and adult offenders between 2007 and 2017.
You can immediately see the rise in the use of immediate custody and the fall in the use of both cautions and community sentences.