The Howard League on Justice priorities

We need more evidence to underpin the decisions made at every level of the criminal justice system, not least of which is sentencing. I would create an institute for evidence-led policy, like the National Institute for Clinical Excellence. Let’s see more use of scientific methodology, such as randomised control trials.

Share This Post

Share on twitter
Share on facebook
Share on linkedin
Share on email

Andrew Neilson (@neilsonandrew) Director of Campaigns at the Howard League for Penal Reform kicks off a new guest blog series setting out his top three priorities for the new Justice Secretary.

If I were Justice Secretary

If I were the incoming Secretary of State for Justice, I would probably be cursing my lot in life.  The Ministry of Justice is not a protected spending department and whoever wins the next election, the axe will swing swift and deep once again.  The job at MoJ will not be prize pickings for anyone with a sense of self-preservation and ambitions for higher office again.

Following time-honoured ministerial advice, I would focus on no more than three priorities while at Petty France.

[divider]

Priority one: Curb sentencing inflation

It is time the nettle is truly grasped and demand on the prisons is curtailed.  I would spend most of my time persuading ministerial colleagues that prison numbers must be brought down.  I wouldn’t rely on a chaotic and artificial market in probation to do this but introduce real sentencing reform focused on the courts.

Forecasts suggest the prison population will continue to rise and the average length of time served has increased by 24% in the last ten years.  This simply isn’t tenable going forward.  I would introduce measures to reverse this inflationary trend and to curb the power of magistrates to send people to prison for short sentences.

[divider]

 Priority two: Women and children first

If our sinking penal system is the Titanic, then the old cry to the lifeboats should sound again.  The numbers of women and children in prison are small and the youth custody population in particular has seen a substantial decline under the Coalition’s watch.  Pioneering approaches with these groups could presage a better future for everyone that currently goes to prison.

The Corston agenda should be implemented in full and the women’s prisons closed for good.  I would reverse the mad plan to build a giant child prison and look again at shrinking the child population further.  A radical drop in numbers would force the case for closing inadequate and antiquated child prisons.

[divider]

Priority three: Put evidence and justice at the heart of the system

We need more evidence to underpin the decisions made at every level of the criminal justice system, not least of which is sentencing.  I would create an institute for evidence-led policy, like the National Institute for Clinical Excellence.  Let’s see more use of scientific methodology, such as randomised control trials.

All too often the justice system is full of injustice.  I would strike a blow against this by addressing the scandal of prisoners still serving the abolished indeterminate sentence for public protection (IPP).  A system to fast-track the review of cases would target the unacceptable situation where the entire IPP population with a tariff of less than two years is now post-tariff.

Finally, there have been some contentious changes to the Incentives and Earned Privileges (IEP) Scheme in prison.  Despite some recent progress on the issue of books (I wonder why), it is high time the meddling of ministers in such matters came to an end.  I would reverse all the changes made to prison regimes by the previous incumbent.

 

The purpose of this blog series is to stimulate a debate about where our criminal justice system should be heading.

I’d love to hear your thoughts on what the justice priorities should be.

Please use the comments section below or follow the conversation on Twitter, using the hashtag #nextGrayling

Share This Post

Share on twitter
Share on facebook
Share on linkedin
Share on email

Related posts

On Probation
The Probation Institute’s Justice priorities

Splitting up responsibility for offender management has created a divide between a small national probation service and the 21 CRCs leading a huge increase in bureaucracy and growing professional tensions. The probation profession is potentially being undermined as there is no longer a requirement for CRCs to use staff with recognised probation qualifications. They no longer have to employ qualified probation officers to manage complex cases.

Featured
The Prison Governors’ Association justice priorities

We cannot go on thinking we can imprison our way to a safer society, not only is it poor value for money for the taxpayer, it also fails to recognise the evidence already available that there are better and more cost effective ways to protect the public and reduce reoffending.

On Probation
Justice should embrace the treasury

It is this relentless focus on ensuring that everything we do actually achieves our aims that is desperately needed in crime and justice policy. To do something radical such as cutting prison numbers, a new Justice Secretary will need allies and I think the best bet is the Treasury.

On Probation
If NoOffence! were Justice Secretary

The design of the CJS is not evidence-led, despite some attempts to reference evidence when it fits the prevailing ‘politics’. The prevailing ‘politics’ and public attitude is one of punishment first and foremost . Any discussion is predominantly an emotional response to the harm done by those who commit crimes, bounded by vested interests and political dogma.

On Probation
If Mike Maiden was Justice Secretary…

I want a public sector provider that sits at the heart of the process. I can’t turn the clock back but I can make sure that one part of the system takes overall responsibility. It’s got to be the public sector because I can’t see that justice and transparency are served by any other sector playing the role.

On Probation
If Ellie Cumbo were justice secretary

There are a hundred things I’d like to do as my third priority, like reverse the cuts to prison budgets or fully implement the Corston review. But unless I also happened to have time-shifting superpowers, the likelihood is that I couldn’t afford any of them. But there is one more thing that’s fairly inexpensive, cannot be cast as either soft or illiberal and would finally bring a much-n

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

All Probation Posts are sponsored by Unilink

With over 20 years’ experience in the criminal justice sector, Unilink is a world leader in probation and community corrections software applications, as well as prisoner self-service, prisoner/case management and prisoner communications. Unilink’s integrated suite of products provide a complete digital solution enabling efficient running of prisons and probation. Underpinned by biometrics it integrates seamlessly to deliver security, efficiency and value – while being proven to help rehabilitate prisoners.

keep informed

One email every day at noon