The Howard League asks whether we have the right outcomes for re-offending payment by results schemes

In this latest in a series of short video interviews on payment by results, Andrew Neilson, Director of Campaigns at the Howard League for Penal Reform, gives his views on PbR in the criminal justice system.

Andrew welcomes the focus on outcomes that PbR brings but wonders whether the current pilots are really about payment by results.

He cautions that the road to desistance from crime can be slow and that a simple binary measure of re-offending (a simple Yes/No recording of whether someone has been reconvicted in the year following an intervention) may be inappropriate.

Do you think the criminal justice PbR pilots are going to herald a new approach to commissioning services for offenders?

Please comment below.

You can follow Andrew on Twitter – @NeilsonAndrew

 

You can see all the video interviews in this series with a wide range of viewpoints pro and con PbR from different perspectives here.




Leave a Reply

Delphic oracle
What does recovery mean and how do we measure it?
shortage
The impact of a shortage of heroin
injection trainer
Preventing heroin deaths with take-home naloxone
heroin poppy
Interesting alcohol and drug facts January 2016
s300_number10
Review of racial bias in justice sytem
injustice
Joint enterprise criminalises young BAME people
hidden hurt
The hidden hurt of violence against women
gangs
Ending gang violence and exploitation
transition
Transitions from young to adult offender remain poor
justice data lab
The Justice Data Lab gets more useful
House of Common TR FI
The official history of Transforming Rehabilitation so far
probation-unpaid-work-inspe
Unpaid work irrelevant to broader probation supervision
drink driving
What do we know about drink drivers?
car theft
Is car theft a thing of the past?
postcodes
Rape prosecution is a postcode lottery
police sns
Big fall in Stop and Search
prison reform
Will we really see prison reform?
mental health eggs
Improving the mental health of prisoners
prison break
How many prisoners are released by mistake?
empty prison
Prisons and prevention
Payment by Results
why child
Why commission by payment by results?
front cover1
Payment by Results: Lessons from the Literature
empty prison
Prisons and prevention
Finally Friday Social Media Innovation Why I Tweet
Unlock Youtube
Unlocking offenders’ doors to employment
digital govt
Digital government extends its reach
SocialMediaAndCrime-FI
Social media and crime
crazy laws FI
I’m arresting you for…
cities
The most violent cities in the world
noose 2
Which countries execute the most people?
JRFI
Justice Reinvestment

Keep up to date on drugs, crime & PbR

Every new post straight to your inbox