The Howard League asks whether we have the right outcomes for re-offending payment by results schemes

In this latest in a series of short video interviews on payment by results, Andrew Neilson, Director of Campaigns at the Howard League for Penal Reform, gives his views on PbR in the criminal justice system.

Andrew welcomes the focus on outcomes that PbR brings but wonders whether the current pilots are really about payment by results.

He cautions that the road to desistance from crime can be slow and that a simple binary measure of re-offending (a simple Yes/No recording of whether someone has been reconvicted in the year following an intervention) may be inappropriate.

Do you think the criminal justice PbR pilots are going to herald a new approach to commissioning services for offenders?

Please comment below.

You can follow Andrew on Twitter – @NeilsonAndrew

 

You can see all the video interviews in this series with a wide range of viewpoints pro and con PbR from different perspectives here.

Leave a Reply

Select Language
EMCDDA 16 drug deaths
The latest drug-related harms and responses
Andrew Brown June 16
Interesting drug and alcohol facts June 2016
EMCDDA cocaine FI
What drugs are Europeans using in 2016?
Drugwise NPS
Everything you need to know about legal highs
gavel court room
Early guilty pleas may force up prison population
reflections
Refreshing your perspective with peer research
women who kill dv
What happens to women who kill their abusers?
in care out of trouble
In Care, Out of Trouble
JFH FI
Jobs, Friends and Houses
Business success symbol and conquering adversity as a group of people running from one cliff to another with the help of a pencil acting as a bridge in a concept for bridging the gap to achieve a goal.
Will privatisation lead to innovation in probation?
hiker-on-top-of-rock-FI
What next for probation?
Privatisation word cloud
Think Tank urges complete privatisation of probation
paper clips
Myth: Only radical reforms can reduce crime
crime headlines
Why do we always think crime is rising?
3d rendering the empty room with open window
Time for a sensible debate on crime?
Close up of a line of British Police do not cross tape.
10 key facts from the latest crime figures
Carlile 10
Over 4,000 children injured when restrained in custody
RSA transitions
The future prison
gavel court room
Early guilty pleas may force up prison population
penal reform 2016 FI
Global Prison Trends 2016
Payment by Results
evolving tomatoes
The evolution of Social Impact Bonds
swift
Payment by Results and international aid
Equations
What we know about payment by results
Finally Friday Social Media Innovation Why I Tweet
AG FI
The law and social media
Unlock Youtube
Unlocking offenders’ doors to employment
digital govt
Digital government extends its reach
MoJ women in cj stats FI
Women and the Criminal Justice System
AG FI
The law and social media
Wooden gallows rope and noose in St Augustine Florida
Global executions at a 25 year high
Balaclava girl
Crime accounts for 1.5% of world GDP

Keep up to date on drugs, crime & PbR

Every new post straight to your inbox