Menu
prison-phone1FI
Russell Webster

Russell Webster

Criminal Justice & substance misuse expert and author of this blog.

Stopping the use of phones in prison

Share on twitter
Share on facebook
Share on linkedin
Share on print
Share on email
However, new mobile jamming equipment trialled in Scotland in Spring 2014 is reported to be more successful with just over 200 mobiles detected in HMP Shotts and HMP Glenochil during the first six weeks – more than double the amount confiscated in the whole of the previous year.

Illicit prison phones to be cut off

Last week (5 January 2015) the MoJ issued a press release from Prisons Minister Andrew Selous announcing an amendment to the Serious Crime Bill which would compel phone networks to block mobile phones and SIM cards which were being used illegally in prison.

There are a number of problems with illegal mobile phones inside. The main ones being bullying and prisoners who continue to run drug dealing operations from inside or intimidate witnesses to try to stop them appearing at upcoming trials. The problem has certainly got much worse over the years – in 2013 a total of 7451 mobile phones or SIM cards were seized in English and Welsh prisons (up from 6959 the previous year).

Of course, communication between prisoners and home is essential and the slow introduction of phones in prison cells in some English (privately run) prisons is a very positive step in the right direction.

However, the focus of this post is the different approaches that prison authorities have taken to blocking the use of phones inside.

[divider]

Current approaches

In addition to the usual searching procedures, the Prison (Interference with Wireless Technology) Act 2012 enabled the Justice Minister to authorise prison governors to use blocking technology to detect and investigate the use of mobile phones inside.

These powers were tried in a number of prisons but proved largely ineffective since it was difficult to limit the technology to prison accommodation without affecting nearby buildings. The same approach was tried in India and proved problematic there too. However, new mobile jamming equipment trialled in Scotland in Spring 2014 is reported to be more successful with just over 200 mobiles detected in HMP Shotts and HMP Glenochil during the first six weeks – more than double the amount confiscated in the whole of the previous year.

Prison authorities in Mississippi also tried jamming phones but this turned out to be both illegal and impractical with prison staff not being out to use their phones for legitimate reasons. So, in 2010, they implemented and managed their own cellular access system at the Parchman state penitentiary  (very well known to blues fans mainly for the number of recordings made there by Alan Lomax).

Essentially, the prison cell site becomes the preferred network for anyone trying to use a mobile phone inside. This enables calls from approved phones to be passed on to their normal network, but transmissions from unknown or unapproved phones can be blocked. The system is not foolproof, but is reported to have greatly reduced the use of illegal phones.

[divider]

The new amendment

Details of how the MoJ’s proposed new powers will work are limited in the press release but it seems clear that prisons will have to apply to the courts for each number they find to be illegally operating inside.

This seems to be a rather cumbersome, lengthy and potentially expensive process which makes me wonder how much the new amendment will be used in practice.

Certainly the MoJ will want to be seen to be doing something to restrict the number of articles in the press featuring selfies posted to Facebook from inside prison walls, such as this one in last week’s Daily Mirror. The ones below all featured in the national or local press over the last two years:

prison selfie

prison selfie2prison selfie 3

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

If you work in a prison and have experience of tackling the use of phones inside, please share any news and views by the comment section below.

 

Related posts you might like:

A successful approach to tackling drug-related crime

These are outstanding outcomes and demonstrate the importance of a recovery-oriented treatment approach as a long term solution to tackling drug-related crime; interestingly, reconviction rates for RAPt graduates go down further in the second year post-release. Unfortunately, less than 2% of the prison population who currently need this sort of intensive intervention is receiving it. It remains to be seen if Michael Gove, the new Justice Secretary, can improve on that figure.

Read More »

Substance misuse and mental health in prison

Bradley found that mental health and substance misuse services in prisons did not work well together and that this situation did not improve in the five years between his two reports. RAPt’s experience is that only the minority of inmates with acute mental health problems currently receive treatment in prison, with the majority having to cope with their problems in a hostile prison environment without dedicated support.

Read More »

Tackling drug-related crime

Changes in probation and substance misuse commissioning, combined with the very significant cuts to the prison system, have made it much more difficult for drug and/or alcohol dependent offenders to get the treatment which they need to achieve recovery, in which society needs to tackle crime.

Read More »

Reducing smoking in prison

The PHE report summarises our understanding of smoking in prison. On the one hand, limited access to tobacco can reduce how much and how often prisoners smoke as can the cost of tobacco for those surviving on a prison income.

Conversely, smoking is often seen as a coping strategy to manage the stress of imprisonment and helps to alleviate boredom. Not smoking in a culture where a large majority of people smoke can also be socially isolating. And, of course “Burn” remains one of the principal prison currencies.

Read More »

If Alex Cavendish were Justice Secretary

At the moment our prisons are a ticking time bomb that could explode into violence without warning. Frontline staff shortages and overcrowding are contributing to this explosive and toxic environment. If I were Secretary of State for Justice my first priority would be to ensure that no prison in England and Wales has less staff than it needs to operate a safe, normal regime.

Read More »

The Prison Governors’ Association justice priorities

We cannot go on thinking we can imprison our way to a safer society, not only is it poor value for money for the taxpayer, it also fails to recognise the evidence already available that there are better and more cost effective ways to protect the public and reduce reoffending.

Read More »
Share on twitter
Share on facebook
Share on linkedin
Share on print
Share on email

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

A bespoke service

We understand that each client has differing needs and concerns. We can assist and discuss with you in advance the likely difficulties and challenges you will face in prison including, Sentence Mitigation Reports, categorisation, disciplinary proceedings, prison transfers, Release on Temporary Licence through to eventual release and living on licence in the community.

First time in Prison?

Steve Dagworthy, founder of Prison Consultants Limited, talks about prison life.

Keep up-to-date on drugs and crime

You will get one email with a new article every day.