Probation Trust open-minded about payment by results (PbRVideo#1)

Share This Post

Share on twitter
Share on facebook
Share on linkedin
Share on email

Welcome to the first in a new series of short video interviews with key figures involved in PbR which will be running every Monday through September and October.

Mike Maiden is Chief Executive of Staffordshire and West Midlands Probation Trust.

SWMPT is one of two probation trusts (the other one is the Wales Probation Trust) operating Ministry of Justice PbR pilots aimed at improving re-offending outcomes with offenders on community orders through partnership work with the private and voluntary sectors.

Mike sets out his plans, hopes and fears for the pilot below:

I was particularly interested to hear Mike say that he thought the pilot might give SWMPT the chance to operate in a less bureaucratic manner.

What do you think?

You can follow Mike Maiden on Twitter at @CXSWM

 

If you’d like to be interviewed for this PbR series, please get in touch – my contact details are at the top of the home page.

 

You can see all the video interviews in this series with a wide range of viewpoints pro and con PbR from different perspectives here.

Share This Post

Share on twitter
Share on facebook
Share on linkedin
Share on email

Related posts

Payment by Results
PbR jargon demystified (1) A-F

First in a series of infographics which demystify the jargon and technical terms associated with the payment by results commissioning model.

Payment by Results
Prisons and prevention

New IPPR report advocates devolving responsibility for low level offenders to local authorities and City mayors. But do we need another probation service?

Featured
Peterborough Prison PbR pilot results improving, but still below target

However, if the offender population in Peterborough is typical of local prisons, these results are promising although they do not reach the 10% target figure which would release the full PbR payment (the number of reconviction events would need to be 148 per 100 offenders rather than the current 155).

Payment by Results
What did we learn from the Doncaster prison PbR reoffending pilot?

Sodexo and NACRO are the new partnership running the South Yorkshire Community Rehabilitation Company and it will be interesting to see whether they can have a positive impact on reducing the reoffending of released prisoners – their results will also be subject to a payment by results contracting approach, this time using both a binary and frequency (but not severity of offence) payment model.

Disappointing outcomes for Peterborough and Doncaster prison PbR pilots

These are very disappointing results for the MoJ. Normally, there would be an expectation of a high level of performance from pilots with such public exposure where the partners had chosen to participate and, indeed, had championed and driven the initiative from the outset. Therefore, it is an extremely worrying sign for the new private providers of probation whose revenue will be, to an increasing extent, dependent on reducing reoffending rates, that these high-profile pilots are performing so poorly.

On Probation
Did Peterborough and Doncaster reoffending pilots succeed?

So what do we make of these results? To me they represent a mixed picture, there’s no denying that reoffending has been reduced. However, we would normally expect a high level of performance from such a high profile pilot where the partners had chosen to participate and indeed championed and driven the initiative from the outset. On the other hand, there has been significant learning about how best to co-ordinate pre-and post-release activity, use mentors effectively and co-ordinate a multi-agency approach to preventing reoffending.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

keep informed

One email every day at noon